Showing posts with label conservation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label conservation. Show all posts

Friday, April 01, 2022

Rubber and the Path to Preserving Biodiversity


 "El Sendero de la Anaconda" or the Path of the Anaconda, must be one of the most impressive documentaries I have seen recently. It is gentle, persuasive storytelling that weaves history, science and adventure to tell us about our fragile ecosystems, and the urgent need to preserve it for the future generations.

Strange as it may sound, the film does not feature any Anaconda snakes, let alone any other exotic creatures of the Amazon forests. It is instead the story of a student tracing the path taken by his teacher about 80 years ago. It is also the story of how rubber got tangled with the fate of this planet.

The teacher in this story is Prof. Richard Evans Schultes, and his student is a Canadian author named Wade Davis. Schultes is considered the father of modern ethnobotany, who is perhaps more famous among junkies of this world for his greatest popular book, "The Plants of the Gods: Their Sacred, Healing, and Hallucinogenic Powers" (1979).

A few decades before he popularised hallucinogenic concoctions such as ayahuasca, he was roped in by the US government for an important project during the second world war. In 1940, 95% of the world's rubber supply was grown in roughly 12 million acres of plantations of South East Asia.  Within six weeks of the attack on Pearl Harbour, the Japanese had seized control of literally the entire world's supply. The supply of rubber had become so crucial to the war effort that an alternative source had to be found. This source lay in the original mother lode of the rubber tree - the Amazon forests. 

However the problem was that South America is also home to the most potent fungal disease affecting this tree -- the South American Leaf Blight. It is because of this disease that the British created large rubber plantations in South East Asia (SEA), far from the Amazon basin, in areas where the fungal disease had not yet taken root. Prof. Schultes was given the task of finding a species of the rubber tree that was resistant to fungal disease,  so that rubber production could be jacked up from 50,000T a year in the Americas, to over a million tonnes, to break the Asian monopoly.

Prof. Schultes' mission in 1943 was to travel up the Vaupés River, somehow find a way overland to the headwaters of the Rio Apaporis, and then to determine the quantum of rubber that could be  extracted from the area...but as he moved overland, coming to the confluence of the Macayá and the Ajajú, he found himself the mountains of Chiribiquete, the fountain of the rivers of Colombia, where - 

An area the size of the full moon probably had 300-400 million individual rubber trees, of three different species, producing high quality latex...among them was a tree resistant to the blight and high yielding...it was like looking for a needle in a haystack...and he found it! - in the Leticia, in the homeland of the Ticunas, he found what the rubber barons would call "the real bleeders"...and with this he laid the foundation of an America based rubber industry.

All this effort came to naught however with the discovery of synthetic rubber. The US State Department took over this project, and in a fit of bureaucratic insanity, destroyed the clonal gardens. Later, better sense prevailed with the realisation that synthetic rubber just could not replace natural rubber completely.

However two developments were not anticipated - one - the radial tyre that must have natural rubber in the sidewall and the belt for strength, but even more importantly, the development of the modern airline industry. On every plane you have ever flown on, those tires are cut 100% from a tree. Only natural rubber has the qualities that allow it to go from the sub-zero temperatures of high altitude to the shock and impact of hitting the tarmac at 250 kmph, within a period of 10 minutes. Because of this we use more natural rubber than ever before and it still is derived from SEAsia from trees that are essentially genetic clones of the original seeds Wickham took out in 1877.

So, in a sense, we are now back to square one. Nearly all the rubber plantations in SEA continue to be vulnerable to fungal blight -  a single act of biological terrorism, or the accidental introduction of the spore to SEA will completely disrupt the industry. 

Hence a global effort to create a 'Path of the Anacondas' - an ecological and cultural corridor extended all the way from the Andes to the Atlantic, covering eight countries in the upper Amazon basin - Brazil , Colombia, Peru, Ecuador, Venezuela and the three Guineas.

Now, what exactly is a "cultural corridor"? Wade Davis explains this beautifully: 

Children in the Northern Americas are raised to think of mountains a piles or rock, while those in the South grow up with the belief that mountains are the abodes of spirits. These belief systems manifests itself in culture with profound ecological consequences.

Culture is not trivial; culture is not decorative; culture is not the songs we sing, the prayers we utter. Ultimately culture is about a body of moral and ethical values that we place around each individual human being, to keep at bay the barbaric heart that history so sadly teaches us lies within all of us. And so the maintenance of cultural integrity is the maintenance of civilisation itself. Cultural diversity is not an academic conceit -  it is a fundamental indication of the way things are meant to be.

"El Sendero de la Anaconda" conveys its story very effectively indeed with an engaging narrative, superb photos and drone-videos, and a haunting music score. It leaves two questions unanswered  - what happened to that fungus-resistant strain of the rubber tree discovered by Prof. Schultes ? Why has it not been used to replace all the old plantations in SEA and elsewhere?

---------------------------------------------

LINKS & REFERENCES

* Wendt, Paul (1947): The Control of Rubber in World War II - https://www.jstor.org/stable/1053336

* UNESCO World Heritage List - Chiribiquete National Park - https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1174/




Thursday, March 24, 2022

Silvia's World

"You are not just the drop in the ocean. You are the mighty ocean in the drop." - Rumi


It is difficult to associate the mighty oceans with the word 'vulnerable'. 

After all there are few things as humbling as standing on a beach, facing an immense expanse of blue, watching the waves come crashing down, the sting of the salty spray in your eyes, and your body getting tossed around like around like a twig in the surf.

My own introduction to the world of oceans started with a visit to Kanyakumari where, on a clear day, it is possible to see the three different hues of blue that make the Arabian Sea, the Bay of Bengal, and the Indian Ocean. The expanse was however too vast to be covered in small fishing boats so we always saw this world through the eyes of great explorers - the books written by David Attenborough, the tele-series by Jacques-Yues Cousteau, and the paintings of Katsushika Hokusai.

So when one of the most respected marine biologists of the world, Silvia Earle, tells us that the oceans are dying, it  does sound a bit incredulous, almost unbelievable. Silvia is however familiar with this sort of reaction - she has been observing the oceans for over 80 years now. Her dissertation in 1954 was on brown algae; in 1964 she was part of a pioneering International Indian Ocean Expedition, and has seen first had the transformation being brought about by human interventions by way of commercial fishing, oil-spills, nuclear tests, and global warming.

Perhaps this is the ultimate Tragedy of the Commons where the stakeholders are not just communities that share a resource but entire countries and continents. With support from TED, Silvia launched Mission Blue, for setting up marine protected "hope spots" across the globe. In 2014, less than 3 percent of the oceans were protected, and Mission Blue aimed to bring this to 20 percent by 2020. 

Has it worked?

I have not been able to find data on this from the one institution that is supposed to be tracking this issue - the United Nations Conference to Support the Implementation of Sustainable Development Goal 14 (conserve and sustainably use the oceans). Under "Deliverables" it simply states - 'Designation of 30 new Hope Spots by 2020'. The Mission-Blue website however claims that over 44 percent  (40 million sq.km) of the Global Ocean is under Hope Spot designation.

It is not clear if the designation of a zone as a Hot Spot leads to its protection under international covenants. There is also no sign of reduction in the quantum of marine products consumed, which stood at 174.6 million tonnes in 2020.

Silvia has spent a lifetime trying to convince the world about the importance of conserving the oceans. If the UN reports are anything to go by, it seems much work remains to be done.

-------------------------------------

LINKS & REFERENCES

https://www.esri.com/arcgis-blog/products/story-maps/sharing-collaboration/mission-blue-stories-inspire-action-to-explore-and-protect-the-ocean/

https://www.iucn.org/theme/marine-and-polar/our-work/marine-protected-area

https://www.iucn.org/news/secretariat/201609/new-ocean-hope-spots-vetted-iucn-and-mission-blue-ignite-global-support-ocean-protection

https://www.greenfacts.org/en/fisheries/l-2/06-fish-consumption.htm#0

Mission Blue - https://mission-blue.org/

TED Video - My Wish - Protect Our Oceans - https://www.ted.com/talks/sylvia_earle_my_wish_protect_our_oceans?language=en 

4 Ways to Get People to Care - https://ideas.ted.com/4-ways-to-get-people-to-care-about-the-ocean/ 


Wednesday, April 19, 2017

Zero Energy Building




A rather unusual looking building came up in South Delhi a couple of years ago. Amidst other, conventional government buildings in the Jor Bagh area, "Paryavaran Bhavan", the new office of the Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF), looks as though its wearing a graduation cap.

A  closer look reveals that the cap is actually an elongated, cantilevered roof which holds a vast array of solar panels. This seven-storied tower covering 32,000 sq.m, and accommodating over 600 government officials is India's first "Net Zero Energy" building. The solar panels generate 930 KWp of power, which is more than enough to meet its annual energy requirements of 1.4 million Units at 9KWh. The building actually generates a surplus of about 70,000 KWh which diverted back into the grid.

According to MoEF, this "Multi-storied Building with 100% Onsite Power Generation", is the first of its kind in India. Apart from those solar panels on the roof, it uses a Chilled Beam System of air conditioning which saves more than 50% in energy consumption. The building incorporates a Geothermal Heat Exchange System as well as seven "Machine Room Gearless Lifts (OTIS) that converts braking energy into electrical energy (regenerative brakes, as in automobiles). The building also has its own plants for water and sewage treatment -- in other words, it neither takes any energy from outside, neither does it dump its waste into the city's drains.

Who were the people behind such a pioneering effort? How did the usually hidebound CPWD, with its record of making dreadful looking public buildings actually undertake this leap of faith and technical flourish?

Unfortunately, there seems to be nothing in the 'public domain' that either chronicles, or celebrates this achievement. The CPWD website (accessed 19 April 2017), does have a  button titled "Click Here for Old PPTs", and this does lead to a list of projects that includes this building. None of the URLs work.

Dig a little deeper at other websites (ICFILD, CSE) and you would find that CPWD did indeed lack in-house expertise for such a project. So the government did the the next best thing - it employed competent consulting agencies for each of the specialized aspects of this project. CPWD then brought in its formidable project management skills and completed this building in just two years' time (Jan. 2011-Oct 2013). Among them was Deependra Prashad's DPAP -  the architecture firm that designed this building.

Is this new approach going to be the new norm in public works? Have we finally graduated to better designed public buildings?


--------------------------------------------------------
LINKS & REFERENCES

- MOEF Pamphlet - "A New Benchmark in Sustainable Built Habitat"
- CPWD - PPT - Technical Presentation - http://cpwd.gov.in/CPWDNationBuilding/InaugurationPM25.02.2014/Technical_Presentation.ppt
- Case Study (2014) - http://icfild.org/ire2014/seminar/06_deependra_prasad/spa_ipb_deependra.pdf
- Ramachandran, Smriti Kak (2012) - A Green Revolution in Letter and Spirit - http://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/Delhi/a-green-revolution-in-letter-and-in-spirit/article3820306.ece

---------------------------------------------------------
VITAL STATS

Capacity of power generation: 930 KWp
Annual energy requirement and generation: 14 Lakh Units 9KWh
Total area covered by solar panels: 4600 sqm
Building plinth area: 32,000 sqm
Structure: G + 7 floors + 3 basements
Solar Panels: Covering 4600 sqm, monocrystalline with 20% efficiency
Amenities: 440 TR HVAC Air Conditioning; Lifts, Fire Alarm System; DG Sets, UPS, IBMS and CCTV Systems; Fully automatic robotic car parking for 330 cars
Architecture, Planning and Execution: Central Public Works Department (CPWD)
Cost: INR 209 Cr. (USD 32.4 million)

Friday, July 01, 2016

Captain Sparrow




Has there really been a shap decline the population of House Sparrows in India? In our corner of the National Capital Region (Noida) evidence points the other way.

This summer our home seems to have become the favoured destination for a variety of creatures. A couple of squirrels have claimed the space under a bedroom airconditioner; A pigeon laid two eggs on another window ledge, a tennis-ball-sized honeycomb nest on the foyer roof is home to family of yellow wasps, and the fourth corner of the house is the domain of Captain Sparrow and his family.

Three years ago, four organisations - BNHS, MoEF, NCBS and NCF -  had launched a two-month campaign to build public awareness on the disappearing House Sparrow. While participating in the nation-wide "Citizen Sparrow"survey I had pointed out that, at least in Noida, there was absolutely no shortage of this little bird. They were all over the place - in the hedges, on the Arjuna trees, and all over the local vegetable market. 

As if to reinforce this data-point, Captain Sparrow landed on one of our windows that just would not close. In this gap, safe from the prying claws of crows, rats and black-shouldered kites, it started making a tentative nest. At first it was a shoddy piece of work and none of his girlfriends were impressed. He then added a roof, some extra furnishings, and got steady with one. 

First it was a single, tiny, speckled egg. 


A week later there were three more.  


All four eggs went out of sight for a while until one morning we discovered that there were two plump little chicks in the nest. 


Every morning they made a huge racket and Captain and his wife seemed to be perpetually going to and fro getting them things to eat. If any of us approached the nest for a peek, the chicks would quickly backtrack in to the deepest corner, turning themselves completely silent and invisible against the straws and twigs.


Then, as suddenly as they had come, both the chicks turned into young ladies and flew away. So that was that we thought, time to clean up the window sill and settle down for some peace and quiet. 

We then went off on a three week holiday in mid-May. When we returned home in the June, not only had Captain refurbished his hangout, it was now a plush nest with two more chicks! 


So in just one summer, our window sill has been a maternity ward that has seen four baby sparrows fly out into the world.

Will Captain Sparrow come back again next season? We hope so!

--------------------------------------------------------
LINKS

* Citizen Sparrow - http://www.citizensparrow.in/
* India Searches for its missing sparrows (2012) - http://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/Delhi/india-searches-for-its-missing-sparrows/article3287189.ece
* Citizen Sparrow Survey Report (2013)




Thursday, March 31, 2016

An Almost Happy Country



Tshering Tobgay is an amazingly gifted communicator. As the Prime Minister of Bhutan, he comes through as a person with a fine sense of humor, one who has an endearingly hesitant, modest way of connecting with his audience.

Seeing this TED presentation brought back memories of my own trips to Bhutan in in the late 1990s as a part of the JICA team for evaluating the Paro Valley Agriculture Development Project. Of the crisp, clean air, chunky furniture at Tashi Delek hotel, cheerful government officials in white woolen shawls, and of the surreal feel of a country where the citizens were told what to wear, how to build & decorate houses, and what to see on television.

Tobgay's eloquence on Gross National Happiness also made me wonder about the 100,000 ethnic Nepali's who had been expelled from Bhutan in the 1990s. That is one in every seven Bhutanese. Perhaps it is easier to find happiness after a successful round of ethnic cleansing... or perhaps such a move only rankles those who have lived most of their lives in multi-everything countries.

I am also curious to learn more about "Bhutan for Life" which is being described as 'an innovative funding initiative' for ensuring conservation of natural resources, in perpetuity. WWF-Bhutan provides a sketchy outline of the scheme and Tobgay's had claimed in his presentation that the fund - "multi-party single-closing deal"  - based on Wall Street practices, would be ready by the 'end of the year'.

Where can I find details of the this fund? Who are the donors involved here? What is their pound of flesh?

------------------------------------------------------
REFERENCES and LINKS

* Tshering Tobgay, PM of Bhutan - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tshering_Tobgay
* TED Talk transcript - https://www.ted.com/talks/tshering_tobgay_this_country_isn_t_just_carbon_neutral_it_s_carbon_negative/transcript?language=en
* Dowling, Tim (2015): Unhappy? Welcome to Bhutan - the nation of 90% Joy -- http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/nov/04/unhappy-bhutan-joy-happiness-gdp
* Forbes () - Bhutan for Life - http://www.forbes.com/pictures/mjh45egflj/bhutan-for-life-a-conse/
* WWF Bhutan - http://www.wwfbhutan.org.bt/bhutan_for_life/






Sunday, January 04, 2015

Birding Tips from Bharatpur




In 1938 a hunting party led by the British Viceroy, Linlithgow killed 4,237 birds in one day at Bharatpur. From the look of it, the bird sanctuary is yet to recover from the assault.

Keoladeo National Park does has its bright side, even on cold foggy mornings. Despite the poor infrastructure and facilities, the guides are quite sharp with their spotting scopes. If you find the guides too expensive at Rs.250/hour, the rickshaw drivers (Rs.100/hr) are quite good too.

Plastic bags and packaged eatables are banned in the park. At the far end of KNP, you find a tea stall that stocks biscuits and chips but if you decide to buy a flex-packet, the shopkeeper neatly empties its contents into an less-than-glamorous looking newspaper-envelope before handing it out. So he keeps the packet and you get the chips!

A few other travel tips:

  • Ashok hotel is the best location - it built right inside the park. However, you cannot drive your car in... getting there needs the help of rickshaws
  • The best way to go around is on bicycles. The best ones are usually rented out as soon as the park opens at 6:30 AM... almost none are available by 10AM
  • Take your own snacks (eco-packed), flask along...there is practically nothing available inside
  • The Memento shop has nice pullovers and jackets
  • The surrounding countryside has lots of birds too (like the Sarus Cranes atop)